THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Monticello, NY - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated August 2024 (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“Solaia offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere, with a hospitable host and attentive staff who cater to the individual needs of diners. The menu features a wide variety of fresh, high-quality dishes, including delectable options like grilled octopus, calamari, clams, and cod fish in red sauce. The Chilean Sea Bass and desserts are particularly noteworthy, while the drinks and service are also exceptional. The restaurant is family-owned, with the owners and their children playing an active role in providing excellent service and creating a classy ambiance.”

Customers` Favorites

“Ciao Bella offers fine dining in a beautiful ambiance, perfect for special occasions. The food is exceptional, with dishes like chicken parm, tiramisu, Fettuccine boscaiola, veal Marsala, and chocolate mousse cake. The service is top-notch, with the owner going above and beyond to make guests feel welcome. However, the dining room can get loud due to poor acoustics, affecting the overall experience. Despite this, the restaurant is highly recommended for its delicious Italian cuisine and outstanding service. Whether you're a local or just passing through Monticello, Ciao Bella is a must-visit spot that promises a memorable dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Annie's HomeStyle Kitchen offers an incredible dining experience with massive portions and great service. The food, including the popular chicken and waffles, is absolutely amazing, leaving customers satisfied and eager to return. The restaurant is praised for its scrumptious dishes, generous portions, and kind staff, creating a welcoming atmosphere. Customers highlight the variety of delectable options, from perfectly flavored chicken to delicious fried fish, greens, and yams, reminiscent of homemade cooking. Overall, Annie's HomeStyle Kitchen is a hidden gem that consistently delivers an exceptional dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Yanni's Gyro Express is a restaurant known for its gyros and other offerings such as lamb, burgers, and paninis. The chicken kabobs, homemade sweet potato fries, and steak and cheese sub are particularly praised. Dessert options include ekmek and Neapolitan, as well as a highly recommended cheesecake baklava. The restaurant has a convenient drive-up window for pick-up. While the food is consistently good and the staff is friendly, there have been some complaints about customer service. Some customers have reported issues with missing items in their orders and feeling rushed during the ordering process. The restaurant's decor could also benefit from some dusting.”

Customers` Favorites

“Savory Sweet Eatery is a must-try spot with incredible homemade food. From vegan options like the chocolate chip cookie to mom's stuffed burger, everything is cooked fresh to order. The friendly service and delicious burgers, fried chicken sandwiches, and unique sauces make it a hidden gem worth visiting. Don't be fooled by the small appearance - the food and welcoming owner make it a delightful dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Albella Restaurant is a must-visit spot in Monticello NY. The manicotti with cheese sauce and stuffed mushrooms are delicious. The recent upgrades in the restaurant are outstanding. They make their own pasta and serve freshly baked bread with a nice crust. Brie, the waitress, provides top-notch service and treats customers like regulars. Don't miss out on the impeccable food and amazing service at Albella Restaurant. Highly recommended if you're in the area!”

Customers` Favorites

“El Tequilero Mexican Restaurant serves delicious and fresh food, with friendly staff always ready to help. The atmosphere is cozy and traditional, and their specials, such as Birria, are out of this world. Perfect for families, with kids being well taken care of.”

Customers` Favorites

“Fialkoff's Kosher Pizza is a bustling eatery that serves delicious kosher food. The pizza is a highlight, with a crowd of customers enjoying their meals. The service has improved, creating a welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant is kid-friendly, with grandkids loving the food. Parking is available on the side, and the location is wheelchair accessible via a ramp. The menu features a famous potato knish, as well as options like white pizza, mushroom calzone, and spicy fries. With great food, nice staff, and a clean environment, Fialkoff's is a must-visit spot.”

Customers` Favorites

“Salt & Pepper the Kitchen is a standout restaurant that excels in service and atmosphere. The friendly wait staff, possibly including one of the owners, go above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience. The menu offers unique dishes, such as the "Italian" sandwich, bulgogi platter, and spicy chicken platter, all of which are expertly prepared and reasonably priced. The kitchen takes pride in its cooking, ensuring that each dish is made to perfection, with nothing overcooked. With its small but diverse menu, Salt & Pepper the Kitchen is a must-visit for those looking for a memorable meal in Monticello.”

Customers` Favorites

“Colosseo offers a consistently great experience, with fast and high-quality food, excellent service, and affordable prices. The restaurant is a must-visit when in the area. Parking can be limited, especially during peak hours or after events. The menu features specialty slices, and the atmosphere is cozy and welcoming. The staff is friendly and the food is always excellent, making it a highly recommended stop for both locals and visitors.”

Customers` Favorites

“Kennedy Fried Chicken Halal is a highly recommended restaurant offering delicious halal food. The owner is known for being friendly and welcoming, creating a clean and quiet atmosphere. The fish and rice dish is a must-try. With great food and service, this restaurant is sure to provide a positive dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“El Concón is a beloved spot with amazing food, friendly staff, and welcoming owners. The restaurant offers a great variety of fresh dishes in large portions, ensuring a satisfying meal. The clean and fun dining area adds to the pleasant experience, making it a top recommendation.”

Customers` Favorites

“Loved the pizza, my girlfriend had two slices and I ate the rest. Will probably regret it later but definitely recommend. The owners were friendly as well, thank you!”

Customers` Favorites

“Tilly's Diner offers better-than-expected, reasonably priced meals, making it a good stop for travelers passing through. The breakfast menu includes satisfying dishes like eggs, sausage, and home fries. With low prices and a classic diner vibe, it's a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. The fluffy pancakes and French toast are highly recommended, although some areas could benefit from a more thorough cleaning. Overall, Tilly's Diner provides a friendly atmosphere and good food at great prices.”

Customers` Favorites

“La Fondita Mexicana in Monticello, NY is a hidden gem known for its authentic Mexican cuisine. The guacamole is a must-try and sets the tone for a delightful dining experience. The menu offers a wide variety of traditional dishes, with tacos being a particular highlight. Despite slightly slow service, the restaurant is family-friendly and offers great portions at amazing prices. Even picky eaters will be impressed, with dishes like the chimichanga being described as the best ever. Don't miss out on this restaurant if you're in the area—it's simply tremendous!”

“J S Soft Serve offers a delightful ice cream experience with its huge and delicious cones, reasonable prices, and a wide selection of soft serve and regular ice cream flavors. The staff provides excellent customer service, ensuring a pleasant visit for all. Customers frequently return to enjoy the tasty treats at this popular ice cream parlor.”

Customers` Favorites

“Rugelach Heimishe Bakery in Monticello offers a wide variety of delicious pastries, from black and white cookies to different flavors of rugelach. Customers can fill containers with their favorite treats and enjoy fresh coffee as well. This bakery is a hidden gem for those passing through town, with a tempting selection of bread, donuts, cookies, and more.”

Customers` Favorites

“Monticello Bagel Bakery is a beloved institution in the town, serving up delicious bagels and breakfast sandwiches. The bakery offers a wide range of options, including st patties day bagels and NYC-style breakfast sandwiches. Despite some inconsistencies in service, the employees are friendly and take pride in their work. The owner is dedicated to his craft, ensuring that every meal is made with care. With a drive-through and outdoor seating, the bakery is convenient for customers on-the-go. While the prices may be a bit steep for some items, the quality of the goods is consistently high. Overall, Monticello Bagel Bakery is a reliable and tasty spot for a quick bite.”

Customers` Favorites

“Nature's Delight Restaurant offers a large variety of vegetarian foods in a clean and quiet environment. The owner, Dror, provides personalized service and treats every customer like family. The restaurant is praised for its fair prices, delicious food, and quick delivery options. It is also one of the few Kosher restaurants open year-round in the Catskills.”

Customers` Favorites

“Green Shack is a restaurant offering a wide selection of healthy and delicious food, including wraps, salads, smoothies, and Boba drinks. The lady at the counter is friendly and knowledgeable, providing great recommendations. The juices and Thai Boba tea have been praised by customers. However, there have been issues with service and ambiance. The location is across the street from Mountain Physical Therapy in Monticello, and while there is no dedicated parking lot, parking is typically available in front. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible with a ramp on the sidewalk.”

Customers` Favorites

“Cellaio is a favorite among diners, offering an enjoyable meal experience with friendly and knowledgeable staff. Upon entering, guests are greeted warmly by the staff, including standout waiters like Rudy and Rosemary, who provide exceptional service. The menu boasts delicious options, such as Ribeye steaks and filet with potato puree, paired with a great ambiance. The management ensures a courteous and professional atmosphere, making Cellaio a top choice for a memorable dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Fialkoff's Bakery is a friendly, informal spot with a lot of tasty offerings, including the popular onion roll/pocket and delicious babka. Customers enjoy the insanely amazing onion pockets and rugelach, but some find the prices a bit high, like the $40 babka slice. The bakery could benefit from better labeling of items.”

Customers` Favorites

“Dos Gatos Cantina is a fun, cool bar and restaurant that serves delicious, authentic Mexican cuisine. The food is highly recommended, with dishes like quesadillas, mushroom tacos, and sautéed shrimp tacos receiving praise. The restaurant has a great atmosphere, with a separate full bar area and the option to dine inside or outside. While the guacamole may not be a favorite, the overall experience at Dos Gatos Cantina is excellent.”

Customers` Favorites

“Simply Sushi LLC is a great spot for a special occasion or a casual meal. The staff is very nice and kind, making it a welcoming atmosphere. This kosher sushi restaurant serves freshly made dishes with the freshest ingredients. They offer kid-friendly options beyond sushi, and the outdoor seating is phenomenal. With multiple ordering options, including online and in-person, the service is efficient. The salad bar is a highlight, with a helpful staff member preparing orders quickly and accurately. Overall, Simply Sushi LLC is a great choice for eating out or delivery, with healthy options and a good experience guaranteed.”

“Good atmosphere we had a large group and they accommodated us made us a big platter ❤️”

Customers` Favorites

“Good Friends Market offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere with attentive staff. Nena stands out for her exceptional service, making diners feel valued and remembered. The menu features delicious options like Lotus and shrimp appetizers, although some found the lighting too dim. Regulars recommend the orange chicken, shrimp stir fry, and wonton soup. Whether for a casual meal or a special occasion, Good Friends Market promises a satisfying dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“DeFilippis Bakery in Monticello is a local legend known for its amazing assortment of treats like cookies, donuts, and eclairs. The baked goods are so good that it should be illegal, with the grilled chicken and pesto panini being a standout. Visitors are pleasantly surprised by the quality of food and atmosphere, with options like cranberry muffins, breakfast sandwiches, and coffee. The bakery is a hidden gem in Sullivan county, with friendly staff and a community-focused vibe. Whether you're grabbing treats for a crew or looking for a cozy Sunday morning spot, DeFilippis Bakery is a must-visit for delicious local eats.”

Customers` Favorites

“Nelly's Latin Restaurant is a welcoming spot in Monticello, New York, serving delicious food that exceeds expectations. This family-friendly restaurant offers excellent service, making customers feel part of a beautiful paradise. The menu features mouth-watering dishes such as oxtail, roast pork, steak with onions, and amazing pasteles, a Puerto Rican staple. The restaurant is a take-out place, and parking is available behind the building. With its personalized service and great food, Nelly's Latin Restaurant is a must-eat place in town.”

Customers` Favorites

“Giovanni's is a restaurant that has been serving the community for over 30 years, known for its outstanding hero sandwiches, pizza, and Stromboli. The meatballs are made on-site, and the staff is friendly and helpful. The atmosphere is enjoyable, with a comfortable eat-in area and wheelchair accessibility. It's a great place for lunch or a light dinner, and the Godfather, meatball subs, and cheesesteaks are highly recommended.”

Customers` Favorites

“Casa Cava is a kid-friendly restaurant known for its great pizza and fries, accommodating staff, and large seating area. The layout offers a quiet space away from the bustling front, and self-serve pay stations make checkout quick and easy. Ideal for groups, families, or weary travelers, Casa Cava provides excellent service and delicious food.”

Customers` Favorites

“Chinatown Kitchen serves top-notch food, with dishes like house special spaghetti noodles and egg rolls receiving high praise. The service is friendly and great, although some customers have experienced issues with pre-orders and parking. Prices are considered fair, but some customers feel they are high. The restaurant could improve by offering delivery and family deals, which would make it more accessible to families and long-time customers. Overall, Chinatown Kitchen is a recommended spot for good food, despite some minor drawbacks.”

Customers` Favorites

“Great ambiance. Great Food. Great Hosts. Great Location”

Customers` Favorites

“Awesome experience and spectacular food.”

“Wan Bo Buffet is a popular spot for families and locals alike. The restaurant offers a wide variety of buffet dishes, which are constantly refreshed to ensure freshness. The staff is friendly and helpful, making diners feel welcome and valued. While the decor may be a bit dated, the food and service make up for it. Favorites include the jello and donuts, and the lo mein is a crowd-pleaser. Overall, Wan Bo Buffet is a great option for a satisfying meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Lotus is a restaurant that offers a welcoming atmosphere and delicious Asian-inspired dishes. The menu features a variety of options, including shrimp appetizers, steak kew entrees, orange chicken, shrimp stir-fry, and wonton soup. The staff is known for their excellent service and friendliness, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.”